How We Argue: Strategies for Disagreeing with Empathy and Evidence

With roots in Harvard’s Department of Philosophy, ThinkerAnalytix has trained hundreds of educators to strengthen people’s “reasoning muscles” using digital games, puzzles, and practice exercises. 

Cohort learning is at the core of HGSE ethos. This three-week online workshop builds a community of professionals who share reflections, feedback, and implementation strategies.

Each week you will:

• Employ a variety of materials (videos, practice exercises, and games) that can be used off-the-shelf to develop reasoning skills and develop systematic empathy habits of mind.
• Connect with others who share your interest in discussing current events and controversial issues with students and/or colleagues.
• Reflect on how using argument mapping and systematic empathy can support your current practice.

All materials are provided at the start of the program and can be completed within the three-week program period at times that best fit your schedule. Participants should plan to devote approximately five hours of work per week. Participants who complete all individual activities and contribute to group discussions prior to the end of the course period will receive a certificate indicating the completion of fifteen clock hours of instruction.

By the end of the course, participants will:

• Acquire a simple vocabulary for working on arguments across academic disciplines and social settings.
• Analyze and plan arguments using visualization techniques, and help others do the same.
• Teach the steps for listening to better understand the reasons behind different views.
• Help others engage constructively in disagreements about professional, personal, and political topics.

Individual educators may participate in this course, but team enrollment is strongly encouraged. We strongly advise that teams include a cross-section of stakeholders, including:

• Instructors and administrators in middle school, high school, and/or higher education
• Faculty members at universities and community colleges who teach introductory expository writing, law, philosophy, and science writing courses
• Advisors and coordinators of enrichment programs, such as debate teams, forensic teams, model UN, moot court, ethics bowl, social justice groups, and mock trial competitions
• Administrators of associations and organizations, e.g., the National Council of Social Studies, National Council of Principals, and National Association of Social Studies Administrators