EdCast Head Start at a Crossroads: What's at Stake for Children and Families? Katie Hamm explains how a proposed federal overhaul of Head Start could reshape the early education, family support, and quality standards that more than 700,000 children and families rely on Posted November 12, 2026 By News editor Disruption and Crises Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Early Education Education Finances Education Reform Families and Community For more than 60 years, Head Start has been a cornerstone of early childhood education, shaping everything from classroom requirements and family support services to the standards educators are expected to meet. The federally funded program serves more than 700,000 children, and families across the country have come to rely on it. Katie Hamm “Head Start is one of the nation's most successful programs. It's something that Congress has historically, on a bipartisan basis, invested in. And taxpayers and Congress want to know that when they pay for the Head Start model, they are getting the Head Start model,” says Katie Hamm, former deputy assistant secretary for early childhood development at the Administration for Children and Families. “The regulations, the Head Start Performance Standards, are really designed to make sure that we're getting the gold standard in early care and education and that communities can expect that.”But those standards are now in jeopardy. The federal government's proposed changes to Head Start’s quality standards could fundamentally alter the longstanding program and the services families have come to depend on.The proposal drew more than 40,000 public comments in August. It would eliminate 90% of the program’s existing performance standards, raising questions about the future of the services, protections and quality requirements that have defined Head Start for decades.“[Head Start] is really a holistic approach to child development to make sure children from the most impoverished communities around the country have that opportunity to get ready for success in school,” Hamm says. She emphasizes that the program focuses on the whole child, with standards that include family support, nutrition, physical development, medical and dental care, and school readiness.The proposal would let state and local rules determine classroom sizes and child-to-staff ratios; require English-language instruction, with an exception for Tribal languages; remove federal minimums for home visits and protections against suspension or expulsion; drop requirements such as daily toothbrushing and monthly mental-health consultations; and cut the administrative-cost cap from 15% to 5%.The Administration for Children and Families says the proposed changes could allow Head Start to serve 236,000 more children. Its estimate relies largely on reducing administrative spending by about $754 million a year and allowing larger classrooms with fewer teachers per child.“If we have fewer Head Start programs, we obviously can't serve more children,” Hamm says. “The other challenge is with the ratios that they propose to change. That would mean more children in a classroom.”In this episode, Hamm discusses what the proposed changes could mean for children, families, and an already strained early childhood workforce. She challenges the assumption that reducing requirements will necessarily allow Head Start to serve more children and considers how the program can evolve while keeping children at the center of decisions about what makes it effective.In this episode:What the proposed federal overhaul of Head Start’s quality standards could mean for the future of the program.What makes Head Start distinct from other early childhood programs, including its focus on the whole child and comprehensive family services.Why the Head Start Performance Standards matter for ensuring consistent quality and services across communities.The administration’s rationale for reducing regulations — and why critics question whether the proposed changes would improve the program.Whether larger classrooms and reduced administrative costs could realistically allow Head Start to serve more children without additional funding.How the proposed changes could affect children and families experiencing homelessness, including access to services and enrollment flexibility.What the changes could mean for Head Start educators, including classroom conditions, wages, job losses, and workforce retention.What happens next in the federal rulemaking process following the public comment period.How Head Start standards can evolve with research and changing needs while keeping children and families at the center.Transcript:JUNLEI LI: I'm Junlei Li, and this is the Harvard EdCast.This summer, the federal government proposed a major overhaul of Head Start's quality standards. During the 60-day public comment period that followed, these proposed changes drew more than 40,000 public comments. Since 1965, the program has provided preschool and comprehensive supports for children and low-income communities. Why are these standards so important to the $12 billion federal program serving more than 700,000 children and pregnant women each year?Katie Hamm says the changes could fundamentally alter the program and what families can count on. From 2021 to 2025, she served as Deputy Assistant Secretary for Early Childhood Development at the Administration for Children and Families, where she oversaw Head Start. So I asked Katie, what's at stake for children and families if these changes take effect?KATIE HAMM: This is really a fundamental change to Head Start that is on the table. The proposed changes would essentially end Head Start as we know it. I don't think that's an overstatement. It essentially removes the standards that exist today that make sure that no matter where a child attends Head Start, the parent can expect the same level of quality, the same types of services like health and dental checkups, developmental screenings, family support services to address that family and what they need to support themselves. All of those are on the chopping block, so this proposal removes about 90% of the standards that exist today. It actually completely rescinds the performance standards that exist today and replaces them with a much smaller set of standards that are much less specific. And so they don't come with that guarantee that a parent can walk into a Head Start Center in any community in the country and know the quality is going to be the same, the services are going to exist, even if they look different, depending on the community context.And then the standards are replaced by a document that really reflects this administration's priorities. So that includes some changes to nutrition and physical activity, some new requirements around educating families on healthy marriage, and a requirement that services occur in English rather than any other language. So we really see the existing program on the chopping block and a set of standards that would really fundamentally change the program.JUNLEI LI: What makes a program like Head Start distinct within the larger universe of early childhood programs from childcare to preschools to pre-K or kindergarten, that entire spectrum of programs?KATIE HAMM: Head Start began in the 1960s, and it was based on a report put together by the leading developmental psychologists and child development experts at the time, but they really hit the nail on the head in terms of what they envisioned for the Head Start program. So they focus on the whole child. The goal of Head Start is to prepare the child for school, but it is not just about the child's cognitive or academic preparedness. It's about that whole child. So they're looking at the child's physical health. They're looking at socio-emotional development. They're looking at approaches to learning. Is that child excited to go to school? Is that child really jumping in and embracing the lessons and interacting with their peers?And then beyond that, Head Start is also addressing all of the systems and supports around that child. So they meet with parents and they talk about what are the family's strengths? What are the challenges? How can we put together a plan where we partner with the family and really address what are those things that the family needs? They look at nutrition, they look at developmental screenings. A lot of children with disabilities or developmental delays, that's caught when a child goes to Head Start and they get that screening, they do vision, hearing, developmental screenings. And really importantly, Head Start is required to track the follow-up for any issues that were uncovered during those screenings. So if a child, for example, has vision issues, they have to make sure that that child sees an eye doctor. They have to make sure that that child gets eyeglasses or whatever corrective vision devices they might need and help the family access those devices. So it's really a holistic approach to child development to make sure children from the most impoverished communities around the country have that opportunity to get ready for success in school.And that mission is distinct from other early childhood programs. And the standards really reflect that, that it's about the whole child. It's about what we call comprehensive services, which usually refer to the family support, the nutrition, the physical development, referring families to other programs that they have medical or a dental home. All of that is part of Head Start and really fundamental to the mission of Head Start, that children start school ready to learn.JUNLEI LI: I wanted to run by you some of the rationales that have been offered by the current administration officials in proposing that change. From what I can see in their public interviews and comments, the arguments offered for removing what they call the 133 pages of the existing federal requirement is to one, lifting complex requirements and regulations from these programs, serve more children by removing requirements like class sizes, and then to delegate a lot of control to states and maybe even cities that actually support and has the programs. These are fairly common rationale that's offered to remove regulations from a whole host of educational programs, not just the Head Start programs.KATIE HAMM: Yeah, it's a great question. And I think there is a lot of skepticism in the Head Start community that this is a good faith effort. And a lot of that comes from some of the distrust that's evolved over the last 18 months or so. We've seen grant delays, funding delays in Head Start. We have seen a proposed elimination of Head Start that leaked. We've seen the federal staff significantly reduced, which has led to more delays in grants and in getting responses. So I think by the time this proposal came out, there was a lot of skepticism based on people's experiences that this administration and this effort was really aimed at improving the program.When it comes to reducing regulations or deregulations, there certainly is a lot of rhetoric on that. I think it's important to remember that not all regulations are bad. In this case, we have regulations, they're called the Head Start Program Performance Standards that define the minimum requirements for a Head Start program. And that's really important for a parent to know, if I'm sending my child to Head Start, this is the quality that this is what the child is getting. This is the services that a family can expect. It also provides accountability for public taxpayer dollars.Head Start is one of the nation's most successful programs. It's something that Congress has historically on a bipartisan basis invested in. And taxpayers in Congress want to know that when they pay for the Head Start model, they are getting the Head Start model. So in this case, the regulations, the Head Start Performance Standards are really designed to make sure that we're getting the gold standard in early care and education and that the communities can expect that.Certainly, we want to make sure we're reducing burden and paperwork for people who are delivering services for children, and we only want standards in place that are actually needed to deliver a high quality program. The fact that there was such widespread opposition to these standards tells me that they didn't accomplish the goal of reducing burden. And people expressed a lot of concern the result would be lower quality and fewer services for children who are enrolled in Head Start.JUNLEI LI: One of the arguments for reducing regulations, particularly in relation to class size, was to make Head Start more available to hundreds of thousands of children and so on without increasing the overall funding for the program.KATIE HAMM: So the Administration for Children and Families has indicated that they believe that they can serve an additional 236,000 children if they put this proposed change in place. If you look at their own math, which they published alongside their proposal, most of those so-called savings are coming from two places. One is they propose to reduce the amount of administrative costs that a program can use, that the cap is currently 15% of your program funds you can use for administration. They propose to reduce that to 5%. The second place where they're getting these so-called savings is from larger classrooms.I think there are two challenges with that framing. First is many programs have said that without the ability to spend up to 15% on administrative costs, they would have to close their doors. They can't afford to operate if they were to be limited to 5%. So we have a challenge. If we have fewer Head Start programs, we obviously can't serve more children. The other challenge is with the ratios that they propose to change. That would mean more children in a classroom. Head Start already has difficulty recruiting and retaining teachers. It's a really tough job, and wages are low, especially compared to what other employers in the community often pay. Many teachers have said, "I'm already at capacity with the number of children in the classroom and meeting their needs."Head Start is serving more children experiencing homelessness, children who have disabilities or developmental delays. So we don't know how that would be operationalized. How would they get more children in those classrooms if it's not a workload that teachers believe that they can take on? And it's something that programs are already struggling with. So I'm not sure that the math stands up. I would also argue that we don't want to serve more children in Head Start at the cost of undermining quality and services.If we want to serve more children in Head Start, then what the administration and Congress need to look at is how can they appropriate more funding so that programs can afford to keep their doors open, offer more services to children. We have had flat funding in Head Start, no increase from Congress in about three years. And that is happening as programs are seeing their costs skyrocketing. They're seeing higher food costs, higher utilities, payroll increases, rent increases. So they're struggling just to maintain the number of children they're already serving without more funding. So really, the path forward if we want to serve more children is through more funding.JUNLEI LI: I'd like to dive into what changes like this could mean at the level of children or even the educators who work there. So, I know that Head Start have requirements to serve children who are experiencing homelessness. There's approximately, I think, 60,000 children each year that are being served within the Head Start program. So, by removing the regulatory requirements for Head Start to not only work with the families who are experiencing homeless, but other systems that support them, what happens to children and families experiencing homelessness who need the support and the services of the Head Start program?KATIE HAMM: That's a great question. There is reason to be concerned, especially about children experiencing homelessness. One of the current requirements is that programs have to specifically recruit and facilitate the enrollment of children experiencing homelessness and remove barriers to their enrollment. And that includes things like giving families extra time to collect their paperwork. Oftentimes families who are experiencing homelessness, they may have left a domestic violence situation or they may be living in a transitional home or a shelter where they don't have ready access to some of the paperwork that's required for enrollment.One of the major changes that's reflected in the proposed rule is eliminating the ability for families to go through what's called self-attestation. So this is when a family can sign a document that indicates that they meet a certain condition. So an example might be a family that is doubled up couch-surfing or staying with family because of economic reasons without a permanent home, they'd be considered homeless, but there's not a shelter or caseworker necessarily working with them. So they could attest that they are staying with family on a temporary basis because of economic reasons, and that would allow them to be considered a family experiencing homelessness and have some of that flexibility to enroll in Head Start. That would no longer be required.And again, HHS's own analysis suggests that 8% of currently enrolled children would no longer be able to stay in Head Start, and many of those children would be children experiencing homelessness. There's also a current provision that allows Head Start programs to reserve some of their slots for children experiencing homelessness, understanding that that is a family in crisis, and they want to have a slot ready for them when those families unfortunately inevitably show up, that is eliminated. Some of the partnerships with the case workers who work with children experiencing homelessness within the community and the coordination, those requirements are gone.The provision that allows a family to remain enrolled in Head Start, and for staff to continue to work with that family to facilitate enrollment, even if the family moves, we know that often families experiencing homelessness are transient and they might need to move to the next county. That allows the child to have consistency and stay in Head Start. So there are a lot of concerns about children experiencing homelessness in particular. And I would also add that some of the other provisions like tracking that a child gets the developmental screening and any follow up, that's particularly important for families that are experiencing homelessness that get lost in other systems like the healthcare system.JUNLEI LI: What could potentially happen with this set of proposed changes for the educators here?KATIE HAMM: I think there's a lot that's really worrisome for the Head Start workforce. So first and foremost, the administration estimates that about 40,000 Head Start jobs would be cut. And that is because in fewer teachers, if there are higher ratios, that is because some services are cut. And because the proposal includes English only, some teachers who are responsible for supporting dual language learners, those positions are projected to be cut.The other impact is on wages. There's a separate regulatory action that removes some of the standards that were put in place in 2024 to improve Head Start wages and put Head Start educators on the path to parity with kindergarten and public preschool teachers. So those two regulatory efforts kind of sit side by side in a way that really could be harmful to the compensation. The other piece here that's really important to mention, and we talked about this a little bit earlier, is the ratios.A lot of teachers already feel like they're at their max and adding more children to the classroom I think would impact the workforce tremendously, including their decision to remain in Head Start. And then the other thing I want to mention is that there's a provision in the proposed rule that says a program is prohibited from incentivizing or requiring a post-secondary degree or credential unless that program can provide some kind of justification as to why that degree or credential is essential. The concern there is that that could be used to prohibit access to scholarships that allow a teacher to pursue higher education, that it could be used to prohibit financial incentives or wage increases based on the degrees or the training that a teacher has acquired over time. So there's a compounding effect from the proposals in this rule, previous proposals around wages that really could impact compensation, working conditions, retention in a way that's really worrisome.And it's especially worrisome because in the years after the pandemic, Head Start was in a real bind when it came to the workforce. There were a lot of closed classrooms and a lot of programs reporting that they had waiting lists, but they couldn't open their classrooms because they didn't have teachers. And there was a lot of work that programs did to increase those wages to help people in their community, whether those were parents or teachers who were already in their program, get the necessary degrees and requirements to reopen those classrooms. So this really suggests that we might backtrack on that in a way that kind of undermines the overall goal of increasing the number of children served by Head Start. We can't increase the number of children served if we don't have teachers. That's an essential ingredient to deserving children in Head Start. And this rule really would undermine a lot of the efforts that have happened over the last several years to improve recruitment and retention.JUNLEI LI: So what happens now? The public comment period has ended early October. I believe that we're in the review and revision period of the proposed changes. What happens now in the federal government when it comes to a set of changes like this?KATIE HAMM: So we have finished the proposed rule phase in the comment period. Right now, HHS is reviewing those 40,000 comments. They have an obligation to review and respond to those comments in the final rule, and they will also publish a final rule. So the next phase will be a final rule from HHS with a response to the comments. The executive branch, HHS, they have the ability to publish a rule unilaterally. The comments have to be considered and responded to, but it is not a vote. So they still have the ability to make the policy decision that they want to see in Head Start. So I expect in the coming months we will see that final rule.The other important piece of this is we have three branches of government, and as we all know, there are checks and balances that are built into those three branches of government. For those who have looked at the comments, you'll see a lot of questions in those comments about the legality of the proposed rule and some questions about how it conforms or doesn't conform with the Head Start Act. So there is the ability for organizations to bring a lawsuit and challenge the final rule. We've seen that happen in Head Start over the last 18 months with some of the actions on immigration verification and diversity, equity, and inclusion and the federal staff firing. So we'll be watching to see if there is action from the courts. The other branch of government, Congress, can choose to weigh in if they want. They have some tools at their disposal that they can use to prevent the administration from going forward if they so choose.JUNLEI LI: Katie, you've had more than two decades of experience in public policy. Those who are regulated often feel that the regulations are ominous. It translates into more paperwork, more rules to follow, and wish that there were less. And then those who provide the funding and who have administrative responsibilities feels that in order to ensure quality, ensure compliance, we need to have these regulations. And often these two perspectives become these kind of perennial ends of this debate. In your experience, what would be a constructive or productive process that can bring the regulations to both a place where it's feasible and manageable, but also preserves the distinct character and effectiveness of any program?KATIE HAMM: Head Start is a really unique program in that the Head Start Act builds in some requirements for regulation and for the Head Start Program Performance Standards. There's actually a directive to HHS to regularly update the standards and to incorporate the latest information when it comes to child development. So there's a requirement that HHS consult with experts, consult with Head Start programs and staff and parents to make sure that the Head Start standards are a living document, that they evolve as the science evolves. The Head Start program that existed in 1965 is not the Head Start program that would make sense for today's families. So the program is designed to evolve, but it's designed to evolve in a way that centers children and centers their needs.So what I would say is that Head Start should continue to evolve, but it should do so by being led by what's best for children in consultation with experts who know the most recent research on children's health, on children's development, on learning and effective teaching strategies with families and withHead Start staff and directors and people who are serving these families every single day.I think the other thing we need to consider is it's not just the regulations, but it's how those regulations get implemented. So we also have to think about the monitoring protocols. We have to think about how the Office of Head Start functions in a way that is supportive of programs and of children and families. And unfortunately, that office has been cut in half, so we have to think about how the office can also evolve to meet the needs of programs and support them in serving children and families.JUNLEI LI: Thank you so much for helping us understand these issues that often are hidden behind the headlines.KATIE HAMM: Thank you, thanks for having me.JUNLEI LI: Katie Hamm is the former Deputy Assistant Secretary for Early Childhood Development and now a public policy consultant in the field of early childhood. I'm Junlei Li. This is the Harvard EdCast, produced by the Harvard Graduate School of Education. Thanks for listening. EdCast An education podcast that keeps the focus simple: what makes a difference for learners, educators, parents, and communities Explore All Articles Related Articles Usable Knowledge A Look at the Lack of Basic Nurturing Care Worldwide for Preschoolers Research shows that support needs to extend beyond the earliest years. Usable Knowledge Easy as 1, 2, 3 Study examines how parents talk to infants about math. News Widening the Reach for Early Literacy Spanish translation of HGSE’s pre-literacy app Small Wonders, produced by Reach Every Reader and GBH, lets more families play and learn