Skip to main content
EdCast

Do Cellphone Bans Improve Student Achievement? A New Study Finds a Small Boost

Professor Tom Kane examines what a new study of more than 3 million students reveals about cellphone bans and academic achievement
Students' cell phones are neatly organized in a wooden box on a desk, highlighting the policy of limited phone access during classes and promoting focus on learning

Strict cellphone bans in schools may give student achievement a small boost, adding the equivalent of one to two weeks of instruction each year, according to new research by Harvard economist Tom Kane.

The study, which analyzed data from 3 million students and thousands of schools, found that schools using lockable cellphone pouches saw greater academic growth than schools that did not restrict phone access. “What our results suggest today is, yes, cell phones in schools are having a negative impact, at least that's what our findings imply,” Kane says. 

“Since 2013, there's been almost a whole grade equivalent loss in eighth grade math and reading. And what we find is that when you take phones away, you boost achievement growth per year by about half of the rate that it had been declining at,” he says.

Although the gains are modest, Kane points to the potential for academic growth to accumulate over time, and how these bans may offer a more cost-effective intervention. The study found improvements in both math and reading, with similar effects across grade levels and student groups. 

The research also raises a much bigger question: What role has social media use outside school played in the decline in student achievement? While researchers have been able to study the effects of restricting phones in classrooms, they have had little access to the data needed to connect students' social media use with academic outcomes. 

Kane sees a recent settlement between states and Meta as a potential opportunity to close that gap, provided researchers can gain access to meaningful data on how young people use social media.

“It could be that cell phone use out of school are having even bigger negative impacts, but we just don't have the data yet to be able to draw that link as clearly as we should be able to,” he says.

In this EdCast episode, Kane discusses what the new findings reveal about cellphone bans, why even modest gains in achievement matter, and what researchers still need to understand about the relationship between technology and learning. 

In this episode: 

  • Why student achievement has been declining since around 2013, and how that timeline overlaps with the rise of smartphone use among children
  • What a study of 3 million students across thousands of schools found about strict cellphone bans and academic achievement
  • Why cellphone bans produced a modest but meaningful boost equivalent to one or two additional weeks of instruction per year
  • What researchers learned about differences across grade levels, student groups, math, and reading
  • Why taking phones out of classrooms doesn't address the larger question of social media use outside school
  • How the settlement between states and Meta could create new opportunities to study the relationship between social media and student learning
  • What educators and policymakers should consider when implementing cellphone restrictions, including potential unintended consequences

Transcript

JILL ANDERSON: I'm Jill Anderson. This is The Harvard EdCast. 

Harvard economist Tom Kane has spent years tracking a slow, steady decline in student achievement that began around 2013, about the time smartphone use among kids exploded. A lot of people have wondered if the two are connected, so he went looking for answers. He looked at data on more than three million students and over 4,000 schools, comparing schools that locked phones away in Yondr Pouches with similar schools that didn't. The result was a small boost in achievement growth, about one or two extra weeks of instruction a year. 

Kane says that's only part of a bigger story, one we still don't understand: what kids are doing on their phones outside of school and what it means for learning. He's watching a settlement between states and Meta, the parent company of Facebook and Instagram, as one way to find out. I asked what his study tells us about cell phone's possible role in the decline that we didn't already know before.

TOM KANE: Achievement has been declining since around 2013. The declines were slow enough that it took a while for people to even notice that it was happening. But it's sort of like a slow leak in your tire. Once it's been going on for a while, it really adds up. So since 2013, there's been almost a whole grade equivalent loss in eighth grade math and reading. And what we find is that when you take phones away, you boost achievement growth per year by about half of the rate that it had been declining at. Now, cell phone bans don't do anything about out-of-school use of social media, and so we don't know what else was driving achievement down.

JILL ANDERSON: Can you just kind of contextualize that a little bit more for me? Because I know that when someone hears or if someone was to read this latest research, they might say, "Well, that doesn't seem like a lot."

TOM KANE: In any single year, it's small on an annual basis, but big in accumulative basis. It persists over time. We don't know yet how long this boost in achievement growth persists. In our data, we saw up to three years after schools had implemented Yondr bans, and it sure looked like the boost continued through that time. So we don't know whether it'll accumulate, but we do know that the loss is accumulated over time. So it started out about 0.01 to 0.02 standard deviation loss per year that just added up to about a whole grade equivalent. Our estimates of the effect of the strict cell phone bans is equivalent to one or two weeks of additional instruction for the cost of these lockable pouches that we evaluate school districts get an extra one or two weeks of instruction, or another way to put it is an extra two minutes per hour of class time. So it's not a huge effect in any single year, but it's a cost-effective way of getting some additional instruction time.

JILL ANDERSON: And you looked at a huge data set.

TOM KANE: So we had data on 3.3 million students. We had 700 schools that were implementing these lockable pouches. We had 4,200 schools that were matched to serve as comparisons. And it turns out we needed that big of a sample to detect the effects that we were looking for. And we also wanted student level data so that we could see whether there were subgroups of students that were more affected than others. And there, actually we learned that the effects were pretty similar for different subgroups of students, whether it was by gender or by race or by student achievement.

JILL ANDERSON: Can you talk a little bit about some of the research that has happened in this area so far? Because I got the impression that it's been difficult to study how phones may affect children's learning.

TOM KANE: This is actually one of the most amazing things about the situation we're in today. Achievement started to decline 13 years ago, and throughout, I think parents had suspicions and teachers had suspicions that it was related to cell phone use. But actually, even though the social media companies know how much time kids are spending on their platforms, those data have never been linked to academic outcomes and other kinds of outcomes. And we're only able to measure the effect of in-school cell phone use by seeing what happens when schools ban them. So actually we end the paper by saying we need to be learning more about the effect of out-of-school social media use as we're just learning about the impact of in-school social media use.

As I said at the beginning, the achievement declines have been slow, and so we probably should not have been expecting really big impacts in any one year of restricting cell phone access. But I think a lot of people were expecting really big impacts. It's just remarkable how little we know about the impact of cell phones on student learning, even though they've become ubiquitous and parents and a lot of people and teachers are worried about the impacts on kids. We just actually don't have a lot of strong evidence yet.

JILL ANDERSON: It's so fascinating to me how reading was a specific area that showed some potential for growth among some sets of kids. Can you talk a little bit about that?

TOM KANE: Often when we're evaluating the impacts of different kinds of interventions, we find effects in math but not reading. So it was surprising in this study where we're finding effects in both math and reading. And in fact, there were some effects that we only see in reading. I'm not exactly sure what's driving that, except that one of the concerns people have raised about cell phones is there's so much imagery. When kids are staring at their phones, they're not getting practice reading longer form text. And so when you ban the phones in schools, perhaps the reason why we're seeing impacts on reading is students are getting a chance to pay much more attention to the texts that are being discussed in school. We've heard lots of anecdotal evidence from librarians that when cell phone bans go into effect, the number of books checked out of school libraries goes way up, but that'll be a future study to see to what extent that is generally true.

JILL ANDERSON: That's so interesting. And then the other thing I thought was kind of interesting too was you looked at elementary school kids, you looked at middle school kids, you looked at high school kids, and there wasn't a huge difference.

TOM KANE: Yes. Jill, that was something that surprised us too. But remember, we're seeing these impacts in schools that chose to use those lockable pouches and middle schools and high schools were much more likely to choose. So the subset of elementary schools that chose lockable pouches may be schools that had problems with lots of kids using phones. So for whatever reason, we are seeing similar impacts even in the elementary schools that implemented these lockable pouches.

JILL ANDERSON: And just to talk a little bit about something you said earlier, which is that this could be something that can be cost-effective because reading this, you start to think compared to what other interventions might be out there, maybe like extending the school year or the school day or adding high impact tutoring. Even though it seems like a small increase, because I think the study says that it adds a week or two of instruction per year, how do you suggest educators and policymakers weigh this as a meaningful intervention?

TOM KANE: So we are used to evaluating interventions that focus on a subgroup of students, like a tutoring intervention or a summer learning intervention. And most of the research that looks at that kind of intervention finds that they do have bigger effects. So relative to targeted interventions, 0.01 would be a pretty small effect. One or two weeks of additional learning would be small. But because this is so inexpensive and because it applies to the whole school, the effects add up. Being able to produce an extra week or two of instruction for all kids in a school or the average kid in a school is worthwhile, especially when it's cheap to do. And as I said, we expect it will add up just like the initial losses added up over the last 13 years.

JILL ANDERSON: It feels kind of like a no-brainer that this is a good thing to do.

TOM KANE: So we learned it's not a panacea. There were people out there who were thinking, oh, this fundamentally changes the learning process. When we started, we weren't sure what to expect, but we thought one possibility is we'll find big effects. We didn't see any negative side effects of this other than the cost. There's been some other research here in the US that suggests disciplinary actions go up in the year that the bans go in place. That wasn't one of the outcomes we could look at. So if a district were to do this, they should try to keep that in mind and do it in a way where they're tracking what are the disciplinary consequences of the new policy. The nice thing about these pouches is that they reduce the temptation. I think that the bans that just have kids put their phones in their backpack or in their pockets are just tempting kids to break the rules and get in trouble. So schools should be on the watch out for trying to minimize unintended consequences like disciplinary increase. But other than that, we haven't seen evidence of negative consequences.

JILL ANDERSON: There are so many different ways that people are doing this. Like you mentioned in some cases, a school is voluntarily going and getting these Yondr Pouches and having kids put their phones in them. But then we have cases where there's districts and states putting these bans in place, essentially making schools take this kind of action. And I'm wondering if you looked at that and whether you saw any kind of difference in that implementation.

TOM KANE: There were 22 states that implemented some form of ban during the '25, '26 school year. We had data even from just last year. So we were able to compare, okay, so what happened to achievement growth in the states that implemented these bans versus states that had not yet implemented a ban. And what we found were small boosts in achievement growth in those states. Now, we think the strength of that evidence wasn't nearly as strong as the evidence that we had from the Yondr bags, but they were in the same ballpark. These state bans produced about the same small week or two worth of instructional gain per year.

JILL ANDERSON: What were some other big takeaways for you? Because you said you were kind of surprised at these results.

TOM KANE: I really learned a lot by going back to seeing what was the pattern of achievement decline as cell phones were coming in. As researchers, I haven't seen other people say, "Hey, wait a minute, what effect should we expect from a cell phone ban? Shouldn't we go back to see what happened to achievement when cell phones came in and became ubiquitous?" It's in that context that I think even the small effect that we're finding, 0.01 standard deviation gain in achievement growth per year is important because as I said, it was a slow leak to begin with, and it looks like we've plugged about half the leak with a strict cell phone ban, but even slow leaks add up. In a sense, I feel like we discovered something, I hesitate to use the word profound, but how technology has been affecting achievement growth. I think there's been a lot of concern about it, but people have not been thinking about magnitudes of effects. I think the magnitude of effect that we're seeing is certainly consistent with the pattern of decline that we saw before.

JILL ANDERSON: Right. But what you're not saying is that this is responsible for everything and all of the achievement gaps that we see. And as someone who's been studying this for so long, I want you to enlighten us because it's only a piece of a bigger puzzle.

TOM KANE: So it is only a piece. The other piece that, as I said, I'm just amazed that we as a research community don't know more about, and that is the academic consequences of out-of-school cell phone use. And I really hope that we use this Meta settlement as a way to learn more about that. So think about it. We learned about the effect of in-school cell phone use by seeing what happened following these bans. Well, we missed the boat to learn what was the effect of social media outside of school as it was coming in because nobody was collecting the data. Now, under the Meta settlement in which states signed an agreement, including Massachusetts with Meta back in August, we have an opportunity now to see, okay, now that those restrictions are being put in place, what happens to academic outcomes in the schools most affected.

But in order to see that, we're going to need to link the social media data at the school level or at some other aggregate level so that we could trace what are the impacts of these restrictions on student achievement. And not just student achievement, but other measures of student engagement in the world. So extracurricular activities or student mental health. I think there's a lot of largely circumstantial evidence connecting the two, but here would be an opportunity to see what happens following the Meta restrictions. And will states compel other social media platforms that are not part of the Meta settlement like YouTube and TikTok are the two big ones? If those were part of the same settlement and were opposing the same types of restrictions, can we see student outcomes improve or not?

JILL ANDERSON: So is that what you're going to be looking at next?

TOM KANE: I hope so, but a lot depends on what states do, whether states do compel these other platforms to participate. If they don't, by the way, not much will change because kids will just shift from the Meta platforms to YouTube and TikTok. And I hope that states compel the social media companies to share even in an aggregated basis data on the social media use. As you're probably aware, Australia passed a ban on social media that went into effect this past year. There was students under the age of 16. And unfortunately, I've just looked at their evaluation and I don't think they're going to be able to say much beyond the initial impacts of social media on students' self-reported use. They're not going to have good data on actual student social media use. And so in the absence of strong evidence that these restrictions had a positive effect, it's going to be hard to advocate for keeping these restrictions in place. The Meta settlement expires in 10 years, so we have 10 years to fill this hole in evidence that we have on the effect of social media on kids or else it's going to be harder to argue to keep them in place.

JILL ANDERSON: Hearing that and knowing how much of your career you have put into this, I mean, I'm not naive enough to think we could blame cell phones for everything, but it is really scary to think that something that could potentially be responsible for a lot of this is kind of lingering over there in the wings and no one has what they need to be able to really understand it and point a finger at it despite whatever hunches we may have.

TOM KANE: So Jill, I grew up in North Carolina in Winston-Salem where we make cigarettes, and I tell my kids that we used to be able to smoke on airplanes and they're just incredulous like, "Are you kidding me?" Yeah, there used to be in the armrest of airplanes ashtrays. I wonder whether 10 or 15 years from now, my kids are going to be telling their kids, "Can you believe that we used to be able to use our cell phones in schools?" What our results suggest today is yes, cell phones in schools are having a negative impact, at least that's what our findings imply. But it could be that cell phone use out of school are having even bigger negative impacts, but we just don't have the data yet to be able to draw that link as clearly as we should be able to, I think especially just given the depth of parents' concerns about this. And in this case, it really is about our inability to connect the amount of time students are spending on social media, which the social media companies know, with academic outcomes. In this case, it really is data and research that is limiting public knowledge.

JILL ANDERSON: Tom Kane is a professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Education and the faculty director of the Center for Education Policy Research. I'm Jill Anderson. This is The Harvard EdCast, produced by the Harvard Graduate School of Education. Thanks for listening.

EdCast

An education podcast that keeps the focus simple: what makes a difference for learners, educators, parents, and communities

Related Articles