Harvard Graduate School of Education Logo

Give back to HGSE and support the next generation of passionate educators and innovative leaders.

Current Issue

Fall 2020

Svati Lelyveld

Photo: Walter Smith

download a PDF of the article

Svati Mariam Lelyveld, Ed.M.’12

Eighth-Grade Social Studies Teacher | Bronx School of Young Leaders, MS 331 | New York City

It’s the final week of March. We are doing our best to get a rhythm with “remote learning.” The city has promised Wi-Fi enabled iPads that will alleviate the opportunity gap, and some students have received them, but many are still communicating with teachers via cell phone.

I have called all 110 of my eighth-graders at least once. The 27 families in my homeroom are now frequently used contacts in my phone. We have a rapport, via phone. Some families like to chat about the kids’ sadness, others about their own disappointment for canceled events and sources of income.

The phone being my primary mode of contact doesn’t feel great for my work-life balance, but this is an emergency. By now my roles as literacy instructor and history educator are null. My job is to stay in contact with my kids. To make sure they are safe and healthy. That was always part of the job, but now I’m dependent on all of our cell phones working.

It’s the last week of March, and after weeks of calling dozens of families every day, there is a glaring gap in my work: Haleema still hasn’t logged on to my Google classroom. The office administrator has sent me all of the phone numbers listed on Haleema’s emergency card, and after weeks of calling all of them, I am becoming increasingly worried about the child. Haleema is slipping through the cracks that occur when an over exhausted system is asked to work even farther beyond capacity. With no tutor, no Wi-Fi, no guardian at home for dinner time, an overwhelming number of children are relying on our New York City public schools.

Towering at least four inches above me, Haleema has a personality that can captivate any audience. She is easily identifiable as the eighth-grader who can influence an entire cohort of students. Since the first day of school in September, I have had quick conversations with her every morning. Brief reminders that she is smart and beautiful, and can lead her whole crew in the right direction. She sits in the first row of class every day, eventually volunteering her drafts for extra feedback and revision. Her focus starts to spill into her other classes. Her grades are improving. She is getting in trouble less often. That was before the pandemic. Now I can’t find her. I have had no news of Haleema since March 13, 2020.

I’ve been calling her family for weeks, desperate to verify that she is OK. Finally, I send a text message to all of her contact numbers: “Haleema is missing school. The city will have to come make sure she is OK.” I knew the words would be shocking.

“My job is to stay in contact with my kids. To make sure they are safe and healthy. That was always part of the job,  but now I’m dependent on all  of our cell phones working.”

An uncle called me in response to the text message. Grateful to be in contact with him, I implored, “I must make sure Haleema is okay. Please ask her mother to call me.” Within the hour, I received a phone call from Haleema’s mother. She didn’t know why I didn’t have her cell phone number, but in any case, she has been laid off and is home, full time. Thank goodness.

My relationship with Haleema’s mother ended up being one of the greatest successes of parent outreach in my eight years as a NYC public school teacher.

Haleema submitted assignments through her mother’s phone until the city delivered the iPad we had requested for her to continue her schoolwork. The iPad arrived six weeks later, and she was able to use it and excel in her schoolwork for the last two months of the school year.

Haleema’s mother and I texted every day to confirm what assignments had been completed, or to communicate gentle reminders to get them done. In the months of May and June, Haleema was celebrated at our monthly academic awards ceremonies as a student who had perfect attendance, and near perfect scores on all of her work. Those last few months of middle school ended on a high note for everyone, with Haleema’s mother having the time and resources to monitor and nudge her daughter’s remote learning.

Other families, sadly, were not so fortunate. By mid-May, two months into NYC’s shutdown, more and more parents are asking for help with groceries. Some say they already receive one form of food assistance, but it’s not enough. With so many undocumented workers losing their jobs, more families are sharing already strained resources.

Before March 2020, parents had made quick trips to the Caribbean, Central America, and Africa, to visit loved ones, say goodbye to elderly generations, check on family members or homes. All things that immigrants do. But now, with lockdowns, restrictions, loss of income, they can’t come home to New York City. Cell phones are going out of service. A child who was supervised by an older sibling or neighbor for two weeks is now going on the second month without a parent in the house. The students complain of sleep deprivation, inactivity, depression.

The stress is showing on the children. In our Friday social-emotional check ins, they express hopelessness, sadness, and fear for family members who keep our city going as unprotected essential workers. We do our best to continue supporting students through the summer months, connecting families with food pantries and other public health resources. Even as New York City has begun a slow reopening, the outlook for many families has not improved, as most jobs and community resources are still closed.

It’s now the end of July, and I’m still in regular contact with half a dozen of my homeroom students, sharing income and education opportunities as text messages, and admiring their tech savvy emojis and gifs. The resilience of systemically underresourced communities is not magic, or even luck — it is the power of continuous collective care. And cell phone continues to be our primary mode of com munication and connection.

Svati Mariam Lelyveld believes that basic human rights, food, clothing, shelter, and medicine are necessary prerequisites for an adequate education. She is very proud of the students who have made academic progress as they continue to learn about and advocate for their basic human rights.