ED. Magazine

Ed. Extra: Earn to Learn?

By Elaine McArdle
3 Comments

pay_illustration2.jpgIt’s a warm afternoon in May in Boston’s Dorchester neighborhood, and as the bell signals the end of the school day at the Smith Leadership Academy School, kids flood into the halls and burst through the doors outside.

They stop immediately, staring, and begin to point and whisper. Two white stretch limousines are parked at the front of the school building, each with a uniformed chauffeur standing solemnly beside it. The buzz grows louder: Is there a rapper visiting the classrooms? Maybe one of the Boston Celtics has come to get a tour of their new charter school. The kids crowd around the limos, and a few try to climb in.

Finally, when their curiosity climbs to its peak, , ’95 steps to the front of the crowd and motions for the kids to quiet down.

“The limousines are for the students [from a special program] who made honor roll this semester,” she tells them. “Every student who got A’s and B’s on their report card will be driven home in a stretch limo today.”

The children yell and clap, jostling to look at their classmates who won this distinction. A girl steps forward, surprised but grinning, and steps into the limo. A boy proudly follows her, then another. The crowd applauds loudly.

“We want them to think school is cool,” explains Shakur, cofounder and executive director of a unique afterschool program for urban schools in Boston (including Smith Academy) that for more than a decade has racked up impressive results in turning around low-achieving students, in part, by using financial . Building Inspiration to Fight Failure Paradigm Project: A Motivational Learning Skills Program (BIFF), launched 11 years ago by the , is a nine-week program that targets urban students from low- to moderate-income families who are intelligent but lack academic motivation, who would rather be “street smart” than “school smart.” Within just three weeks, it manages to significantly alter students’ effort in class and attitudes toward school, according to a study released last June authored by , Ed.M.’76, C.A.S.’78, ’92, Laura Hsin Feng, Ed.M.’09, and Marisa Whalen, Ed.M.’09. By the end of the program, there is breathtaking change in the group.

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

  • Srividhya

    Very interesting and thought provoking! Every action and step will definitely have pros and cons. Similar is KIPP. Though intrinsic motivation leads to sustained results, extrinsic motivation also plays a role as well. I wonder if the influence of motivation is not universal in nature and believe that it could vary from individual to individual catering to individual differences

  • Bruce Chen

    As a high school teacher, I quite agree that rewarding students’ good behaviors works better than results. Teachers must pay more attention to what students have been doing. However teachers must be cautious, especially when giving money rewards. I am concerned about how students see a money reward and how they relate their behavior to money rewarding. What if the money rewarding system disappear?
    Bruece Chen (42 )
    Director of Academic Affairs, Chushan Senior High School, Taiwan

  • Brian

    I am pleased to see this innovative approach getting attention within the Harvard community. While Kohn often makes convincing arguments, he sights 30 years of research that is weak at best. He also fails to note that 50+ years of research on providing reinforcement, incentives, and rewards is effective at producing a wide-range of (sustainable) desirable outcomes in children, youth, and adults. For example, the Good Behavior Game’s(based on providing reinforcement) use in elementary school has been shown to improve behavior and decrease later substance use during adolescence. I think it is time to get away from the debate on extrinsic vs. intrinsic motivation and realize that people on both sides of the debate do agree on one thing- motivation (regardless of form) is crucial to student learning. Teaching reading and other crucial academic, social and life skills is the goal. If a meager extra incentive further develops a child’s reading abilities and/ or interest in reading, we all need to seriously consider its merits.

Past Issues

Latest Activity